Visser & Drost (No 3) [2024] FedCFamC2F 118
27 March 2024
Ages: Husband (50), Wife (48)
Relationship: 3-year marriage
Children: 1 adult child of the wife from a previous relationship
Asset pool: Non-superannuation property in substance the Suburb C property, valued at $850,000 (inherited by the husband after separation); husband's superannuation almost $400,000
Division: About 10% to the wife for contributions plus 2% for future needs, so 12% of the non-superannuation pool ($102,000), reduced by an earlier $10,000 payment and $9,000 costs to $83,000
Visser & Drost (No 3) [2024] FedCFamC2F 118
Relationship Details
- Type: Marriage
- Duration: Married in 2016, separated on 17 September 2019; divorce finalised in 2022. Total relationship duration was approximately 3 years.
- Ages at Judgment: Husband 50, Wife 48
Children
- Children from Previous Relationships: Wife has a daughter, now an adult, from a previous relationship.
- Other Circumstances: Husband assisted with the child's schooling and expenses during the marriage.
Initial Financial Positions
- Husband:
- Settled property proceedings from his earlier marriage before this one.
- At the start of the marriage: $43,000 in savings, a motor vehicle and $306,342 in superannuation.
- Applied about $90,000 to renovating the Suburb C property (then his parents' home, which he later inherited) before the marriage.
- Wife:
- Evidence regarding initial financial contributions was lacking, including alleged proceeds from the sale of a property in Country D.
Contributions During the Relationship
- Financial Contributions:
- Husband was the sole income earner, responsible for all family expenses, including wife's visa costs and sending her funds.
- Wife contributed minimally as a homemaker; no substantial financial contribution.
- Non-financial Contributions:
- Wife's homemaker contributions were minimal and intermittent, reduced by more than 15 months spent overseas, and their quality was impaired by her family violence towards the husband.
Post-Separation Contributions and Actions
- Financial Contributions:
- Husband continued to pay various household expenses despite being excluded from the Suburb C property.
- Made an interim property payment of $10,000 to the wife under orders made in July 2023.
- Non-financial Contributions:
- Wife occupied the Suburb C property without making significant contributions or payments post-separation.
Current Financial Position & Property Pool
-
Property Pool:
- Suburb C property valued at approximately $850,000. It was inherited by the husband post-separation and remained unencumbered.
-
Superannuation:
- Husband's superannuation: almost $400,000. The husband proposed a superannuation split with a base amount of $50,000 in the wife's favour, and the orders bind the trustee of his superannuation scheme.
Assessment of Contributions and Future Needs
- Contributions:
- Husband's contributions were assessed as overwhelmingly significant compared to Wife’s.
- The wife's contributions were equated with about 10% of the value of the Suburb C property ($85,000).
- Future Needs Adjustments:
- Wife granted an additional 2% adjustment in recognition of limited employment prospects and need for medical interventions.
- Final Division:
- 12% of the non-superannuation pool (in substance 12% of the Suburb C property, $102,000) to the wife. After deducting the $10,000 interim payment and $9,000 in costs thrown away by an adjournment, the husband was to pay her $83,000 within 90 days. The court rejected her claim for $400,000 or 30% of a claimed $1.4 million pool.
Unique Aspects
- The case highlighted the wife's minimal homemaker contributions. The court rejected her allegations of family violence by the husband, accepted his evidence of family violence by her, and found it impaired the quality of her contributions.
- Post-separation, the wife occupied the Suburb C property for about 3 years, yet no financial obligation was undertaken for outgoings.
- The inheritance of the Suburb C property by the husband after the relationship ended was a major factor influencing the court's decision.
- Court deemed it just and equitable to account for the husband's pre-marriage financial contributions towards renovations and his significant financial support.
Conclusion
The overall division accounted for the short duration of the marriage and the overwhelming financial contributions by the Husband, with a future needs adjustment slightly favouring the wife.
The law since this decision
This case was decided before 10 June 2025. From that date the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) sets out the steps for a property settlement in s 79(3) to (5), and the court must consider the effect of family violence on each party's contributions (s 79(4)(ca)) and on their current and future circumstances (s 79(5)(a)), and any material wastage of property (s 79(5)(d)). In Western Australia, a property case between married couples is decided under that Act in the Family Court of Western Australia. A case between de facto partners in Western Australia is decided under the Family Court Act 1997 (WA), which has not adopted those 2025 changes.
These summaries have been generated with the help of artificial intelligence.