Delmont & Simms [2024] FedCFamC2F 113

26 April 2024

Ages: Not specified

Relationship: 26-year de facto

Children: 3, all now adults (the youngest was 16 at separation)

Asset pool: $392,644 (including super)

Division: De facto wife 60%, De facto husband 40%

Delmont & Simms [2024] FedCFamC2F 113

Relationship Details

  • Type: De facto
  • Duration: Approximately 26 years. Relationship commenced in 1995 and ended in August 2020.
  • Ages at Judgment: Not specified in the judgment. The de facto husband brought the case through a litigation guardian.

Children

  • Children from Relationship: Three children, all now adults.
  • Special Circumstances: The youngest had just turned 16 at separation and lived with the de facto wife afterwards.

Initial Financial Positions

  • De Facto Husband: In paid employment at the start; no evidence that he brought in significant assets.
  • De Facto Wife: In paid employment at the start; no evidence that she brought in significant assets. She began receiving a disability support pension in 1995 because of a longstanding medical history.

Contributions During the Relationship

  • Financial Contributions:

    • De facto wife secured a disability support pension in 1995.
    • De facto husband secured a disability support pension in 2013.
    • De facto wife claims she managed the payment of utilities and mortgages during the relationship.
  • Non-financial Contributions:

    • De facto wife was primarily responsible for childcare and homemaking due to her husband's mental health challenges.
    • The husband contributed through "outdoor" maintenance of their properties, whereas the wife contributed through "indoor" tasks.
    • The wife's contributions were described as more arduous due to the husband's perpetration of family violence.

Post-Separation Contributions and Actions

  • Financial Contributions:

    • The wife continued to occupy and contribute financially to the Town C property.
  • Non-financial Contributions:

    • The wife maintained primary care of the youngest child who resided with her post-separation.
  • De facto husband after separation:

    • Made no contributions post-separation; lived with his mother.

Current Financial Position & Property Pool

  • Current Income: Both parties are beneficiaries of disability pensions.
  • Property Pool:
    • Total net pool: $392,644
    • De facto wife seeks to retain her residence at Town C.
    • Superannuation interests total $8,000.
    • Husband's assets valued at $32,000.

Assessment of Contributions and Future Needs

  • Contributions Assessment:

    • Husband's contributions: 40%
    • Wife's contributions: 60%.
    • The wife's contributions were impacted by the husband's perpetration of family violence.
  • Future Needs Adjustments:

    • No adjustment was made: both parties are on disability pensions with no assessed capacity for paid work, and their circumstances were similarly difficult.
    • The orders were framed so that each party's Legal Aid costs would not reduce the other's share.
    • Overall division: 60% to the de facto wife ($235,586), 40% to the de facto husband ($157,058), by a cash payment of $125,058 to him, failing which the Town C property was to be sold.

Unique Aspects

  • Significant context of family violence impacting contributions.
  • The wife endured arduous circumstances during the relationship due to violence perpetrated by the husband; the court relied on, among other things, his own text message to two of the children and NSW Police observations.
  • The wife's aim to retain the Town C property while ensuring a financial settlement to buy out the husband's share.
  • Legal Aid debts by both parties impacting the financial outcome.

Conclusion

The court found a 60:40 property division in favour of the de facto wife to be just and equitable, reflecting her primary caregiving role, financial contributions after separation, and the effect of family violence on her contributions.

The law since this decision

This case was decided before 10 June 2025. From that date the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) sets out the steps for a property settlement between de facto partners in s 90SM(3) to (5), and the court must consider the effect of family violence on each party's contributions (s 90SM(4)(ca)) and on their current and future circumstances (s 90SM(5)(a)), and any material wastage of property (s 90SM(5)(d)). In Western Australia, a property case between married couples is decided under that Act in the Family Court of Western Australia. A case between de facto partners in Western Australia is decided under the Family Court Act 1997 (WA), which has not adopted those 2025 changes.

Citation: Delmont & Simms [2024] FedCFamC2F 113

These summaries have been generated with the help of artificial intelligence.